In an opinion made public on Wednesday, Judge Broderick granted in part and denied in part Keurig’s motion for summary judgment against retailer plaintiffs BJ’s Wholesale Club and Winn-Dixie, in the long-running In re Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serve Coffee Antitrust Litigation MDL. The retailer plaintiffs had adopted several arguments advanced by other plaintiffs in earlier summary judgment briefing that Judge Broderick addressed in a September 2026 opinion. Relying on that decision, Judge Broderick applied many of his earlier rulings to the retailers’ claims.
Keurig began manufacturing single-serve brewers in 1998 and held a patent on its K-Cup filter technology until 2012. After the patent expired, sales of Keurig-compatible coffee pods increased and prices fell. Keurig maintained at least an 80% market share for compatible cups between 2010 and 2019.The retailers allege that, after its K-cup patent expired in 2012, Keurig unlawfully maintained its monopoly over Keurig-compatible pods through conduct such as exclusive deals with roasters, suppliers, and distributors, tying, a redesigned brewer, and misleading advertising.
Keurig argued in part that plaintiffs could not establish monopoly power because numerous competitors had entered the alleged market. Judge Broderick rejected what he called an “overly simplistic assertion,” agreeing with plaintiffs that “the fact of competitive entry . . . alone proves neither a lack of barriers to entry nor a lack of monopoly power.” The court explained:
Continue Reading Judge Broderick: Competitor Market Entry Alone Does Not Defeat Monopoly Claims Against Keurig